Electric power system control with measurement of energy demand and energy efficiency using t-distributions

ABSTRACT

A method, apparatus, system and computer program is provided for controlling an electric power system, including implementation of voltage measurement using paired t statistical analysis applied to calculating a shift in average usage per customer from one time period to another time period for a given electrical use population where the pairing process is optimized using a novel technique to improve the accuracy of the statistical measurement.

This application is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No.14/193,980, filed Feb. 28, 2014, which claims priority under 35 U.S.C.§119(e) to U.S. provisional patent application 61/789,085 filed on Mar.15, 2013, which are hereby incorporated by reference in their entiretyherein. This application is also related to U.S. patent application Ser.No. 14/562,017, filed Feb. 5, 2014 and now abandoned, which is herebyincorporated by reference in its entirety herein.

BACKGROUND

The present disclosure relates to a method, an apparatus, a system and acomputer program for controlling an electric power system, includingmeasuring the effects of optimizing voltage, conserving energy, andreducing demand using t distributions. More particularly, the disclosurerelates to a novel implementation of electrical demand and energyefficiency improvement measurement using a paired samples t-test tocompare the population demand and energy usage over a specific timeperiod. This method enables the direct statistical measurement of energyand demand changes between two time periods for an energy usepopulation. This comparison can be used as a basis to accuratelyquantify energy efficiency and demand reduction values for savingsresulting from implementation of a modification to the electric powersystem.

Electricity is commonly generated at a power station byelectromechanical generators, which are typically driven by heat enginesfueled by chemical combustion or nuclear fission, or driven by kineticenergy flowing from water or wind. The electricity is generally suppliedto end users through transmission grids as an alternating currentsignal. The transmission grids may include a network of power stations,transmission circuits, substations, and the like.

The generated electricity is typically stepped-up in voltage using, forexample, generating step-up transformers, before supplying theelectricity to a transmission system. Stepping up the voltage improvestransmission efficiency by reducing the electrical current flowing inthe transmission system conductors, while keeping the power transmittednearly equal to the power input. The stepped-up voltage electricity isthen transmitted through the transmission system to a distributionsystem, which distributes the electricity to end users. The distributionsystem may include a network that carries electricity from thetransmission system and delivering it to end users. Typically, thenetwork may include medium-voltage (for example, less than 69 kV) powerlines, electrical substations, transformers, low-voltage (for example,less than 1 kV) distribution wiring, electric meters, and the like.

The following, the entirety of which is herein incorporated byreference, describe subject matter related to power generation ordistribution: Power Distribution Planning Reference Book, SecondEdition, H. Lee Willis, 2004; Estimating Methodology for a LargeRegional Application of Conservation Voltage Reduction, J. G. De Steese,S. B. Merrick, B. W. Kennedy, IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 1990;Implementation of Conservation Voltage Reduction at Commonwealth Edison,IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, D. Kirshner, 1990; ConservationVoltage Reduction at Northeast Utilities, D. M. Lauria, IEEE, 1987;Green Circuit Field Demonstrations, EPRI, Palo Alto, Calif., 2009,Report 1016520; Evaluation of Conservation Voltage Reduction (CVR) on aNational Level, PNNL-19596, Prepared for the U.S. Department of Energyunder Contract DE-AC05-76RL01830, Pacific Northwest National Lab, July2010; Utility Distribution System Efficiency Initiative (DEI) Phase 1,Final Market Progress Evaluation Report, No 3, E08-192 (7/2008) E08-192;Simplified Voltage Optimization (VO) Measurement and VerificationProtocol, Simplified VO M&V Protocol Version 1.0, May 4, 2010; MINITABHandbook, Updated for Release 14, fifth edition, Barbara Ryan, BrianJoiner, Jonathan Cryer, Brooks/Cole-Thomson, 2005; Minitab Software,http://www.minitab.com/en-US/products/minitab/; Statistical Softwareprovided by Minitab Corporation.

Further, U.S. patent application Ser. No. 61/176,398, filed on May 7,2009 and US publication 2013/0030591 entitled VOLTAGE CONSERVATION USINGADVANCED METERING INFRASTRUCTURE AND SUBSTATION CENTRALIZED VOLTAGECONTROL, the entirety of which is herein incorporated by reference,describe a voltage control and energy conservation system for anelectric power transmission and distribution grid configured to supplyelectric power to a plurality of user locations.

SUMMARY

Various embodiments described herein provide a novel method, apparatus,system and computer program for controlling an electric power system,including implementation of voltage measurement using paired tstatistical analysis applied to calculating a shift in average usage percustomer from one time period to another time period for a givenelectrical use population where the pairing process is optimized using anovel technique to improve the accuracy of the statistical measurement.

According to an aspect of the disclosure, the energy validation process(EVP) measures the level of change in energy usage for the electricalenergy delivery system (EEDS) that is made up of an energy supply system(ESS) that connects electrically to one or more energy usage systems(EUS). A modification is made to the operation of the EEDS or to anenergy usage device (EUD) at some electrical point on an electricalenergy delivery system (EEDS) made up of many energy usage devicesrandomly using energy at any given time during the measurement. Thepurpose of the energy validation process (EVP) is to measure the levelof change in energy usage for the EEDS. The electrical energy supply tothe electrical energy delivery system (EEDS) is measured in watts,kilowatts (kw), or Megawatts (MW) (a) at the supply point of the ESS and(b) at the energy user system (EUS) or meter point. This measurementrecords the average usage of energy (AUE) at each of the supply andmeter points over set time periods such as one hour.

The test for the level of change in energy use is divided into two basictime periods: The first is the time period when the modification is notoperating, i.e., in the “OFF” state. The second time period is when themodification is operating, i.e., in the “ON” state. Because electricalenergy usage is not constant but varies with other independent variablessuch as weather and ambient conditions, weather and ambient variation aswell as other independent variables must be eliminated from thecomparison of the “OFF” state to the “ON” state. The intent is to leaveonly the one independent variable being measured in the comparison ofaverage energy usage from the “OFF” to the “ON” condition.

To eliminate the effect of the ambient and/or weather conditions apairing process is used to match energy periods with common ambientand/or weather conditions using a pairing process. As an example,temperature, heating degree, cooling degree and other weather conditionsare recorded for each energy measurement over the set time periods.These periods are paired if the temperature, heating degree, coolingdegree and other weather conditions match according to an optimizationprocess for selecting the most accurate pairs.

To eliminate other independent variables not being measured that willcause variation in the measurement, an EEDS of a near identical energysupply system and near identical energy usage system that is located inthe same ambient and/or weather system is used. To eliminate the otherindependent variables, the changes in energy in the EEDS of a nearidentical energy supply system are subtracted from the changes measuredby the EEDS under test. This method corrects the test circuit for theeffects of the other remaining independent variables.

The measurement process consists of first pairing intervals of averageenergy usage data from the “OFF” state to the “ON” state. The first stepis to eliminate significant outliers that are easily identified as notbeing associated with the independent variable. As an example, if theexpected (based on experience or otherwise) load shift resulting from amodification is a maximum of 2 kw and the data shows a population memberwith an load shift of 10 MW, this element can be excluded. Exclusion hasto be done consistently across the population not to destroy thepopulation normality.

The second step is to set the limits of the pairing process. The limitsmay be set based, at least in part, on the accuracy desired. Theaccuracy also depends on the number of data points used. As an example,for temperature difference, a limit might be chosen to be one degreeFahrenheit (F). With this choice of limits, a time period type is chosenover which data measurements are examined. Choice of the time period maydepend on what EEDS operating environment conditions are relevant for achosen analysis. For example, a 24-hour time period may be chosen toinclude the variation of the measured data over a full day. As anotherexample, a four-hour time period in the evening may be chosen to includethe variation of measured data over a peak evening electricity usageperiod.

During the time period, data is collected from a set of sensors in aportion of the EEDS with the modification in the “ON” state. During thesame type time period (which may or may not run concurrently with timeperiod for collection in the “ON” state), data is collected from a groupof sensors that are potential pairs to the set from a portion of theEEDS with the modification in the “OFF” state. The pairs are reviewed toassure that the best match of temperature levels between the match ischosen. This process may be repeated for other variables. Once the bestgroup of pairs is identified, a standard process of paired t is appliedto determine the average change in energy usage from the “OFF” state tothe “ON” state using a t distribution for the group of pairs identified.This process can determine, within a confidence level, the actual rangeof change in energy use from the “OFF” state to the “ON” state for thispopulation. For this process, measurements can be made at the electricalenergy delivery system (EEDS) meter point(s) or at the energy usagesystems (EUS) meter point(s) or with the energy usage device (EUD) meterpoints or any combination of EEDS, EUS and EUD meter points.

The resulting change in energy usage may then be used to control theelectric energy delivery system. For example, components of the EEDS maybe modified, adjusted, added or deleted, including the addition ofcapacitor banks, modification of voltage regulators, changes to end-userequipment to modify customer efficiency, and other control actions.

According to a further aspect of the disclosure, the energy validationprocess (EVP) measures the level of change in energy usage for theelectrical energy delivery system (EEDS) that is made up of an energysupply system (ESS) that connects electrically to one or more energyusage systems (EUS). This is similar to the aspect described above,however multiple modifications are made to EEDS operation or to energyusage devices (EUD) at electrical point(s) on an electrical energydelivery system (EEDS) made up of many energy usage devices randomlyusing energy at any given time during the measurement. The purpose ofthe energy validation process (EVP) is to measure the level of change inenergy usage for the EEDS with combined modifications and with each ofthe individual modifications. The electrical energy supply to theelectrical energy delivery system (EEDS) is measured in watts, kw, or MW(a) at the supply point of the ESS and (b) at the energy user system(EUS) or meter point. This measurement records the average usage ofenergy (AUE) at each of the supply and meter points over set timeperiods such as one hour.

The test for the level of change in energy use improvement is dividedinto two basic time periods: The first is the time period when themodification is not operating, i.e., in the “OFF” state. The second timeperiod is when the modification is operating, i.e., in the “ON” state.Because electrical energy usage is not constant but varies with otherindependent variable such as weather and ambient conditions, weather andambient variation as well as other independent variables must beeliminated from the comparison of the “OFF” state to the “ON” state. Theintent is to leave only the independent variables being measured in thecomparison of average energy usage from the “OFF” to the “ON” condition.

To eliminate the effect of the ambient and/or weather conditions apairing process is used to match energy periods with common ambientand/or weather conditions using a pairing process. As an exampletemperature, heating degree, cooling degree and other weather conditionsare recorded for each energy measurement over the set time periods.These periods are paired if the temperature, heating degree, coolingdegree and other weather conditions match according to an optimizationprocess for selecting the most accurate pairs.

To eliminate other independent variables not being measured that willcause variation in the measurement, an EEDS of a near identical energysupply system and near identical energy usage system that is located inthe same ambient and/or weather system is used. To eliminate the otherindependent variables, the changes in energy in an EEDS of a nearidentical energy supply system are subtracted from the changes measuredby the EEDS under test. This method corrects the test EEDS for theeffects of the other remaining independent variables.

The measurement process consists of first pairing intervals of averageenergy usage data from the “OFF” state to the “ON” state. The first stepis to eliminate significant outliers that are easily identified as notbeing associated with the independent variable. As an example, if theexpected load shift for a modification is a maximum of 2 kw and the datashows a population member with a load shift of 10 MW, this element canbe excluded. Exclusion has to be done consistently across the populationnot to destroy the population normality.

The second step is to set the limits of the pairing process. As anexample for temperature difference a limit might be chosen to be onedegree F. With this choice of limits, similar to the preceding describedaspect, a time period is chosen over which data measurements shall be orhave been taken from a set of sensors with the modification in the “ON”state, and from a group of sensors that are potential pairs to the set,with the modification in the “OFF” state. The pairs are reviewed toassure that the best match of temperature levels between the match ischosen. This is repeated for other variables and once the best group ofpairs is identified, a standard process of paired t is applied todetermine the average change in energy usage from the “OFF” state to the“ON” state using a t distribution for the group of pairs identified.This process can determine within a confidence interval the actual rangeof change in energy use from the “OFF” state to the “ON” state for thispopulation. For this process, measurements can be made at the electricalenergy delivery system (EEDS) meter point(s) or at the energy usagesystems (EUS) meter point(s) or with the energy usage device (EUD) meterpoints or any combination of EEDS, EUS and EUD meter points.

The resulting change in energy usage may then be used to control theelectric energy delivery system. For example, components of the EEDS maybe modified, adjusted, added or deleted, including the addition ofcapacitor banks, modification of voltage regulators, changes to end-userequipment to modify customer efficiency, and other control actions.

The energy validation process (EVP) may further contain a secondindependent variable such as humidity that affects the energy usage. TheEVP is then used to provide a second pairing variable that is secondaryto the first pairing variable. The process pairs the first variable asclose as possible with the population “OFF” to “ON” values for thechosen energy intervals. The matching second variable is already matchedto the first variable for the interval. A weighed scoring of the pairsis implemented based on the relative slopes of the linear relationshipbetween the energy and the respective independent variable. Thisproduces an optimized selection of pairs to most closely match the twopopulation points. This linear optimal matching provides the bestpairing of the data for t-distribution evaluation. This method allowsmultiple values to be optimally paired for calculating average energychanges using the t-distribution.

The energy validation process (EVP) may further contain an electricalenergy delivery system (EEDS) that is made up of an energy supply system(ESS) that connects electrically to one or more energy usage systems(EUS) that has three phases of power. The EVP will then perform allpower and independent variable calculations by phase values in allcombinations of EEDS, ESS, EUS, and EUDs to calculate the energy changesdue to modifications in the energy systems. Thus calculations may beperformed separately using data for sensed properties specific to eachof one of the three phases. In this way, the effects of themodifications to the EEDS for one or more phases may be compared to itseffects for the other phase(s).

The energy validation process (EVP) may further contain a secondindependent variable such as voltage where the ratio of the averagechange in voltage to average change in energy is being calculated or theconservation voltage reduction factor (CVRF). This factor measures thecapacity of the EEDS, EUS and EUD's to change energy usage in responseto the independent variable of voltage. The EVP calculates the CVRFfirst by pairing two energy states from the “OFF” state to the “ON”state as already described. Second the ratio of the percent change inenergy divided by the percent change in voltage for the sample iscalculated between the two states for each sample in the population.Optimal pairing matches the closest samples for evaluation using at-distribution to determine the confidence interval for the averagevalue of the CVRF.

The energy validation process (EVP) may further contain multipleindependent variables such as voltage and circuit unbalance where theratio of the average change in voltage and circuit unbalance to averagechange in energy is being calculated or the energy reduction factor(ERF). This factor measures the capacity of the EEDS, EUS and EUD's tochange energy usage in response to multiple independent variables. TheEVP calculates the ERF first by pairing two energy states from the “OFF”state to the “ON” state as already described. Second the ratio of thechange in energy divided by the change in combined % change of themultiple variables for the sample is calculated between the two statesfor each sample in the population. Optimal pairing matches the closestsamples for evaluation using a t-distribution to determine theconfidence interval for the average value of the ERF.

The energy validation process (EVP) may further contain an electricalenergy delivery system (EEDS) that is made up of an energy supply system(ESS) that connects electrically to one or more energy usage systems(EUS). The EVP evaluation time period (or interval) can be developed inmultiple levels. This is useful to categorize the connected EUD's usinga linear regression technique. As a starting point the interval coulduse the standard interval of 24 hours to capture the effects of loadcycling over multiple hours. But in some cases not all loads will beconnected during the full 24 hours and the energy measurements may notbe consistent over the total period. To address this, for example,evaluations are separated into seasons to represent the different loads,such as air conditioning and heating between the summer and winterseasons respectively. In the fall and spring these loads may not existunder mild weather conditions, so they are evaluated separately as well.In addition each season is evaluated by using linear regression torepresent the multiple variables that affect the loads for each hour,such as heating degree level, cooling degree level, day type (weekend,weekday or holiday), humidity, growth in load, and others. The hours arethen grouped by the regression factor ranges to match the generalcharacteristics of the load. This regression results in dividing eachseason into hour ranges for each 24 hour period that can beindependently compared to determine their separate characteristics ofenergy performance in the population. The EVP will then perform allpower and independent variable calculations by phase values, by season,by hourly ranges in all combinations of EEDS, ESS, EUS, and EUDs tocalculate the energy changes due to modifications in the energy systems.

Additional features, advantages, and embodiments of the disclosure maybe set forth or apparent from consideration of the detailed descriptionand drawings. Moreover, it is to be understood that both the foregoingsummary of the disclosure and the following detailed description areexemplary and intended to provide further explanation without limitingthe scope of the disclosure as claimed.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The accompanying drawings, which are included to provide a furtherunderstanding of the disclosure, are incorporated in and constitute apart of this specification, illustrate embodiments of the disclosure andtogether with the detailed description serve to explain the principlesof the disclosure. No attempt is made to show structural details of thedisclosure in more detail than may be necessary for a fundamentalunderstanding of the disclosure and the various ways in which it may bepracticed. In the drawings:

FIG. 1 shows an example of an EEDS made up of an electricity generationand distribution system connected to customer loads, according toprinciples of the disclosure;

FIG. 2 shows an example of a voltage control and conservation (VCC)system being measured at the ESS meter point and the EUS made up ofAdvanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) measuring Voltage and Energy,according to the principles of the disclosure;

FIG. 3 shows an example of an Energy Validation Process (EVP) accordingto principles of the disclosure;

FIG. 4 shows an example of an Energy Validation Process (EVP) data basestructure according to principles of the disclosure;

FIG. 5 shows an example of general outlier analysis to determinepopulation measurements that are outside of normal operation, accordingto principles of the disclosure;

FIG. 6 shows an example of voltage outlier analysis to determine ifindependent variables such as voltage measurements are outside of normaloperation, according to principles of the disclosure;

FIG. 7 shows examples of graphs of a voltage histograms of “OFF to ON”comparisons for determining the characteristics of the independentvariables, according to principles of the disclosure;

FIG. 8 shows examples of graphs of sample points by weather and seasonin the “ON” and “OFF” conditions to view the characteristics of theweather and seasonal shifts in each sample and sample pair;

FIG. 9 shows an example of the high level pairing process for matchingthe weather, day type, and humidity for a population sample, accordingto the principles of the disclosure;

FIG. 10 shows an example of the results of breaking the load data intogroups by season and by hourly groups with similar characteristics,according to the principles of the disclosure;

FIG. 11 shows an example of a process map of the optimal pairingprocess, according to the principles of the disclosure;

FIG. 12 shows an example of a histogram of the data pairing process todetermine the CVR factor for the EEDS, according to principles of thedisclosure;

FIG. 13 shows an example of an application of a paired test analysisprocess determining the change in usage per customer. The top histogramrepresents the pairing results and the bottom scatter plot demonstratesthe results of the pairing values, according to principles of thedisclosure;

FIG. 14 shows examples of histograms of the data pairing process todetermine the CVR factor for the EEDS, one with a control EEDS to removeother independent variables, and one without the control EEDS, accordingto principles of the disclosure; and

FIG. 15 shows an example of a summary chart for the data shown inprevious Figures on CVR factor and Energy savings per customer,according to principles of the disclosure.

The present disclosure is further described in the detailed descriptionthat follows.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE DISCLOSURE

The disclosure and the various features and advantageous details thereofare explained more fully with reference to the non-limiting embodimentsand examples that are described and/or illustrated in the accompanyingdrawings and detailed in the following description. It should be notedthat the features illustrated in the drawings are not necessarily drawnto scale, and features of one embodiment may be employed with otherembodiments as the skilled artisan would recognize, even if notexplicitly stated herein. Descriptions of well-known components andprocessing techniques may be omitted so as to not unnecessarily obscurethe embodiments of the disclosure. The examples used herein are intendedmerely to facilitate an understanding of ways in which the disclosuremay be practiced and to further enable those of skill in the art topractice the embodiments of the disclosure. Accordingly, the examplesand embodiments herein should not be construed as limiting the scope ofthe disclosure. Moreover, it is noted that like reference numeralsrepresent similar parts throughout the several views of the drawings.

A “computer”, as used in this disclosure, means any machine, device,circuit, component, or module, or any system of machines, devices,circuits, components, modules, or the like, which are capable ofmanipulating data according to one or more instructions, such as, forexample, without limitation, a processor, a microprocessor, a centralprocessing unit, a general purpose computer, a super computer, apersonal computer, a laptop computer, a palmtop computer, a notebookcomputer, a desktop computer, a workstation computer, a server, or thelike, or an array of processors, microprocessors, central processingunits, general purpose computers, super computers, personal computers,laptop computers, palmtop computers, notebook computers, desktopcomputers, workstation computers, servers, or the like.

A “server”, as used in this disclosure, means any combination ofsoftware and/or hardware, including at least one application and/or atleast one computer to perform services for connected clients as part ofa client-server architecture. The at least one server application mayinclude, but is not limited to, for example, an application program thatcan accept connections to service requests from clients by sending backresponses to the clients. The server may be configured to run the atleast one application, often under heavy workloads, unattended, forextended periods of time with minimal human direction. The server mayinclude a plurality of computers configured, with the at least oneapplication being divided among the computers depending upon theworkload. For example, under light loading, the at least one applicationcan run on a single computer. However, under heavy loading, multiplecomputers may be required to run the at least one application. Theserver, or any if its computers, may also be used as a workstation.

A “database”, as used in this disclosure, means any combination ofsoftware and/or hardware, including at least one application and/or atleast one computer. The database may include a structured collection ofrecords or data organized according to a database model, such as, forexample, but not limited to at least one of a relational model, ahierarchical model, a network model or the like. The database mayinclude a database management system application (DBMS) as is known inthe art. At least one application may include, but is not limited to,for example, an application program that can accept connections toservice requests from clients by sending back responses to the clients.The database may be configured to run the at least one application,often under heavy workloads, unattended, for extended periods of timewith minimal human direction.

A “communication link”, as used in this disclosure, means a wired and/orwireless medium that conveys data or information between at least twopoints. The wired or wireless medium may include, for example, ametallic conductor link, a radio frequency (RF) communication link, anInfrared (IR) communication link, an optical communication link, or thelike, without limitation. The RF communication link may include, forexample, WiFi, WiMAX, IEEE 802.11, DECT, 0G, 1G, 2G, 3G or 4G cellularstandards, Bluetooth, and the like.

The terms “including”, “comprising” and variations thereof, as used inthis disclosure, mean “including, but not limited to”, unless expresslyspecified otherwise.

The terms “a”, “an”, and “the”, as used in this disclosure, means “oneor more”, unless expressly specified otherwise.

Devices that are in communication with each other need not be incontinuous communication with each other, unless expressly specifiedotherwise. In addition, devices that are in communication with eachother may communicate directly or indirectly through one or moreintermediaries.

Although process steps, method steps, algorithms, or the like, may bedescribed in a sequential order, such processes, methods and algorithmsmay be configured to work in alternate orders. In other words, anysequence or order of steps that may be described does not necessarilyindicate a requirement that the steps be performed in that order. Thesteps of the processes, methods or algorithms described herein may beperformed in any order practical. Further, some steps may be performedsimultaneously.

When a single device or article is described herein, it will be readilyapparent that more than one device or article may be used in place of asingle device or article. Similarly, where more than one device orarticle is described herein, it will be readily apparent that a singledevice or article may be used in place of the more than one device orarticle. The functionality or the features of a device may bealternatively embodied by one or more other devices which are notexplicitly described as having such functionality or features.

A “computer-readable medium”, as used in this disclosure, means anymedium that participates in providing data (for example, instructions)which may be read by a computer. Such a medium may take many forms,including non-volatile media, volatile media, and transmission media.Non-volatile media may include, for example, optical or magnetic disksand other persistent memory. Volatile media may include dynamic randomaccess memory (DRAM). Transmission media may include coaxial cables,copper wire and fiber optics, including the wires that comprise a systembus coupled to the processor. Transmission media may include or conveyacoustic waves, light waves and electromagnetic emissions, such as thosegenerated during radio frequency (RF) and infrared (IR) datacommunications. Common forms of computer-readable media include, forexample, a floppy disk, a flexible disk, hard disk, magnetic tape, anyother magnetic medium, a CD-ROM, DVD, any other optical medium, punchcards, paper tape, any other physical medium with patterns of holes, aRAM, a PROM, an EPROM, a FLASH-EEPROM, any other memory chip orcartridge, a carrier wave as described hereinafter, or any other mediumfrom which a computer can read.

Various forms of computer readable media may be involved in carryingsequences of instructions to a computer. For example, sequences ofinstruction (i) may be delivered from a RAM to a processor, (ii) may becarried over a wireless transmission medium, and/or (iii) may beformatted according to numerous formats, standards or protocols,including, for example, WiFi, WiMAX, IEEE 802.11, DECT, 0G, 1G, 2G, 3Gor 4G cellular standards, Bluetooth, or the like.

According to one non-limiting example of the disclosure, a voltagecontrol and conservation (VCC) system 200 is provided (shown in FIG. 2)and the EVP is being used to monitor the change in EEDS energy from theVCC. The VCC, which includes three subsystems, including an energydelivery (ED) system 300, an energy control (EC) system 400 and anenergy regulation (ER) system 500. The VCC system 200 is configured tomonitor energy usage at the ED system 300 and determine one or moreenergy delivery parameters at the EC system (or voltage controller) 400.The EC system 400 may then provide the one or more energy deliveryparameters C_(ED) to the ER system 500 to adjust the energy delivered toa plurality of users for maximum energy conservation. The energyvalidation process (EVP) system 600 monitors through communications link610 all metered energy flow and determines the change in energyresulting from a change in voltage control at the ER system. The EVPsystem 600 also reads weather data information through a communicationlink 620 from an appropriate weather station 640 to execute the EVPprocess 630,

The VCC system 200 is also configured to monitor via communication link610 energy change data from EVP system 600 and determine one or moreenergy delivery parameters at the EC system (or voltage controller) 400.The EC system 400 may then provide the one or more energy deliveryparameters C_(ED) to the ER system 500 to adjust the energy delivered toa plurality of users for maximum energy conservation. Similarly, the ECsystem 400 may use the energy change data to control the electric energydelivery system 700 in other ways. For example, components of the EEDS700 may be modified, adjusted, added or deleted, including the additionof capacitor banks, modification of voltage regulators, changes toend-user equipment to modify customer efficiency, and other controlactions.

The VCC system 200 may be integrated into, for example, an existing loadcurtailment plan of an electrical power supply system. The electricalpower supply system may include an emergency voltage reduction plan,which may be activated when one or more predetermined events aretriggered. The predetermined events may include, for example, anemergency, an overheating of electrical conductors, when the electricalpower output from the transformer exceeds, for example, 80% of its powerrating, or the like. The VCC system 200 is configured to yield to theload curtailment plan when the one or more predetermined events aretriggered, allowing the load curtailment plan to be executed to reducethe voltage of the electrical power supplied to the plurality of users.

FIG. 1 is similar to FIG. 1 of US publication 2013/0030591, withoverlays that show an example of an EEDS 700 system, including an EUSsystem 900 and an ESS system 800 based on the electricity generation anddistribution system 100, according to principles of the disclosure. Theelectricity generation and distribution system 100 includes anelectrical power generating station 110, a generating step-uptransformer 120, a substation 130, a plurality of step-down transformers140, 165, 167, and users 150, 160. The electrical power generatingstation 110 generates electrical power that is supplied to the step-uptransformer 120. The step-up transformer steps-up the voltage of theelectrical power and supplies the stepped-up electrical power to anelectrical transmission media 125. The ESS 800 includes the station 110,the step-up transformer 120, the substation 130, the step-downtransformers 140, 165, 167, the ER 500 as described herein, and theelectrical transmission media, including media 125, for transmitting thepower from the station 110 to users 150, 160. The EUS 900 includes theED 300 system as described herein, and a number of energy usage devices(EUD) 920 that may be consumers of power, or loads, including customerequipment and the like.

As seen in FIG. 1, the electrical transmission media may include wireconductors, which may be carried above ground by, for example, utilitypoles 127 and/or underground by, for example, shielded conductors (notshown). The electrical power is supplied from the step-up transformer120 to the substation 130 as electrical power E_(In)(t), where theelectrical power E_(In) in MegaWatts (MW) may vary as a function of timet. The substation 130 converts the received electrical power E_(In)(t)to E_(Supply)(t) and supplies the converted electrical powerE_(Supply)(t) to the plurality of users 150, 160. The substation 130 mayadjustably transform the voltage component V_(In)(t) of the receivedelectrical power E_(In)(t) by, for example, stepping-down the voltagebefore supplying the electrical power E_(Supply)(t) to the users 150,160. The electrical power E_(Supply)(t) supplied from the substation 130may be received by the step-down transformers 140, 165, 167 and suppliedto the users 150, 160 through a transmission medium 142, 162, such as,for example, but not limited to, underground electrical conductors(and/or above ground electrical conductors).

Each of the users 150, 160 may include an Advanced Meter Infrastructure(AMI) 155, 169. The AMI 155, 169 may be coupled to a Regional OperationsCenter (ROC) 180. The ROC 180 may be coupled to the AMI 155, 169, bymeans of a plurality of communication links 175, 184, 188, a network 170and/or a wireless communication system 190. The wireless communicationsystem 190 may include, but is not limited to, for example, an RFtransceiver, a satellite transceiver, and/or the like.

The network 170 may include, for example, at least one of the Internet,a local area network (LAN), a wide area network (WAN), a metropolitanarea network (MAN), a personal area network (PAN), a campus areanetwork, a corporate area network, the electrical transmission media125, 135 and transformers 140, 165, 167, a global area network (GAN), abroadband area network (BAN), or the like, any of which may beconfigured to communicate data via a wireless and/or a wiredcommunication medium. The network 170 may be configured to include anetwork topology such as, for example, a ring, a mesh, a line, a tree, astar, a bus, a full connection, or the like.

The AMI 155, 169 may include any one or more of the following: A smartmeter; a network interface (for example, a WAN interface, or the like);firmware; software; hardware; and the like. The smart meter may beconfigured to determine any one or more of the following:kilo-Watt-hours (kWh) delivered; kWh received; kWh delivered plus kWhreceived; kWh delivered minus kWh received; interval data; demand data;voltage; current; phase; and the like. If the smart meter is a threephase meter, then the low phase voltage may be used in the averagecalculation, or the values for each phase may be used independently. Ifthe meter is a single phase meter, then the single voltage componentwill be averaged.

The AMI 155, 169 may further include one or more collectors (shown inFIG. 2) configured to collect smart meter data from one or more smartmeters tasked with, for example, measuring and reporting electric powerdelivery and consumption at one or more of the users 150, 160.Alternatively (or additionally), the one or more collectors may belocated external to the users 150, 160, such as, for example, in ahousing holding the step-down transformers 140, 165, 167. Each of thecollectors may be configured to communicate with the ROC 180.

VCC System 200

FIG. 2 shows an example of the VCC system 200 with the EVP system 600monitoring the change in energy resulting from the VCC controlling theEEDS in the more efficient lower 5% band of voltage, according toprinciples of the disclosure. The VCC system 200 includes the ED system300, the EC system 400 and the ER system 500, each of which is shown asa broken-line ellipse. The VCC system 200 is configured to monitorenergy usage at the ED system 300. The ED system 300 monitors energyusage at one or more users 150, 160 (shown in FIG. 1) and sends energyusage information to the EC system 400. The EC system 400 processes theenergy usage information and generates one or more energy deliveryparameters C_(ED), which it sends to the ER system 500. The ER system500 receives the one or more energy delivery parameters C_(ED) andadjusts the electrical power E_(Supply)(t) supplied to the users 150,160 based on the received energy delivery parameters C_(ED). The EVPsystem 600 receives the weather data and the energy usage data andcalculates the energy usage improvement from the VCC.

The VCC system 200 minimizes power system losses, reduces user energyconsumption and provides precise user voltage control. The VCC system200 may include a closed loop process control application that uses uservoltage data provided by the ED system 300 to control, for example, avoltage set point V_(SP) on a distribution circuit (not shown) withinthe ER system 500. That is, the VCC system 200 may control the voltagesV_(Supply)(t) of the electrical power E_(Supply)(t) supplied to theusers 150, 160, by adjusting the voltage set point V_(SP) of thedistribution circuit in the ER system 500, which may include, forexample, one or more load tap changing (LTC) transformers, one or morevoltage regulators, or other voltage controlling equipment to maintain atighter band of operation of the voltages V_(Delivered)(t) of theelectric power E_(Delivered)(t) delivered to the users 150, 160, tolower power losses and facilitate efficient use of electrical powerE_(Delivered)(t) at the user locations 150 or 160.

The VCC system 200 controls or adjusts the voltage V_(supply)(t) of theelectrical power E_(Supply)(t) supplied from the EC system 500 based onsmart meter data, which includes measured voltage V_(meter)(t) data fromthe users 150, 160 in the ED system 300, and based on validation datafrom the EVP system 600. The VCC system 200 may adjust the voltage setpoint V_(SP) at the substation or line regulator level in the ER system500 by, for example, adjusting the LTC transformer (not shown), circuitregulators (not shown), or the like, to maintain the user voltagesV_(Meter)(t) in a target voltage band V_(Band-n), which may include asafe nominal operating range.

The VCC system 200 is configured to maintain the electrical powerE_(delivered)(t) delivered to the users 150, 160 within one or morevoltage bands V_(Band-n). For example, the energy may be delivered intwo or more voltage bands V_(Band-n) substantially simultaneously, wherethe two or more voltage bands may be substantially the same ordifferent. The value V_(Band-n) may be determined by the followingexpression [1]:

V _(Band-n) =V _(SP) +ΔV   [1]

where V_(Band-n) is a range of voltages, n is a positive integer greaterthan zero corresponding to the number of voltage bands V_(Band) that maybe handled at substantially the same time, V_(SP) is the voltage setpoint value and ΔV is a voltage deviation range.

For example, the VCC system 200 may maintain the electrical powerE_(Delivered)(t) delivered to the users 150, 160 within a bandV_(Band-1) equal to, for example, 111V to 129V for rural applications,where V_(SP) is set to 120V and ΔV is set to a deviation ofseven-and-one-half percent (+/−7.5%). Similarly, the VCC system 200 maymaintain the electrical power E_(Delivered)(t) delivered to the users150, 160 within a band V_(Band-2) equal to, for example, 114V to 126Vfor urban applications, where V_(SP) is set to 120V and ΔV is set to adeviation of five (+/−5%).

The VCC system 200 may maintain the electrical power E_(Delivered)(t)delivered to the users 150, 160 at any voltage band V_(Band-n) usable bythe users 150, 160, by determining appropriate values for V_(SP) and ΔV.In this regard, the values V_(SP) and ΔV may be determined by the ECsystem 400 based on the energy usage information for users 150, 160,received from the ED system 300.

The EC system 400 may send the V_(SP) and ΔV values to the ER system 500as energy delivery parameters C_(ED), which may also include the valueV_(band-n). The ER system 500 may then control and maintain the voltageV_(Delivered)(t) of the electrical power E_(Delivered)(t) delivered tothe users 150, 160, within the voltage band V_(Band-n). The energydelivery parameters C_(ED) may further include, for example,load-tap-changer (LTC) control commands.

The EVP system 600 may further measure and validate energy savings bycomparing energy usage by the users 150, 160 before a change in thevoltage set point value V_(SP) (or voltage band V_(Band-n)) to theenergy usage by the users 150, 160 after a change in the voltage setpoint value V_(SP) (or voltage band V_(Band-n)), according to principlesof the disclosure. These measurements and validations may be used todetermine the effect in overall energy savings by, for example, loweringthe voltage V_(Delivered)(t) of the electrical power E_(Delivered)(t)delivered to the users 150, 160, and to determine optimal deliveryvoltage bands V_(Band-n) for the energy power E_(Delivered)(t) deliveredto the users 150, 160.

ER System 500

The ER system 500 may communicate with the ED system 300 and/or ECsystem 400 by means of the network 170. The ER system 500 is coupled tothe network 170 and the EC system 400 by means of communication links510 and 430, respectively. The EC system 500 is also coupled to the EDsystem 300 by means of the power lines 340, which may includecommunication links.

The ER system 500 includes a substation 530 which receives theelectrical power supply E_(In)(t) from, for example, the powergenerating station 110 (shown in FIG. 1) on a line 520. The electricalpower E_(In)(t) includes a voltage V_(In)(t) component and a currentI_(In)(t) component. The substation 530 adjustably transforms thereceived electrical power E_(In)(t) to, for example, reduce (orstep-down) the voltage component V_(In)(t) of the electrical powerE_(In)(t) to a voltage value V_(Supply)(t) of the electrical powerE_(Supply)(t) supplied to the plurality of smart meters 330 on the powersupply lines 340.

The substation 530 may include a transformer (not shown), such as, forexample, a load tap change (LTC) transformer. In this regard, thesubstation 530 may further include an automatic tap changer mechanism(not shown), which is configured to automatically change the taps on theLTC transformer. The tap changer mechanism may change the taps on theLTC transformer either on-load (on-load tap changer, or OLTC) oroff-load, or both. The tap changer mechanism may be motor driven andcomputer controlled. The substation 530 may also include a buck/boosttransformer to adjust and maximize the power factor of the electricalpower E_(Delivered)(t) supplied to the users on power supply lines 340.

Additionally (or alternatively), the substation 530 may include one ormore voltage regulators, or other voltage controlling equipment, asknown by those having ordinary skill in the art, that may be controlledto maintain the output the voltage component V_(Supply)(t) of theelectrical power E_(Supply)(t) at a predetermined voltage value orwithin a predetermined range of voltage values.

The substation 530 receives the energy delivery parameters C_(ED) fromthe EC system 400 on the communication link 430. The energy deliveryparameters C_(ED) may include, for example, load tap coefficients whenan LTC transformer is used to step-down the input voltage componentV_(In)(t) of the electrical power E_(In)(t) to the voltage componentV_(Supply)(t) of the electrical power E_(Supply)(t) supplied to the EDsystem 300. In this regard, the load tap coefficients may be used by theER system 500 to keep the voltage component V_(Supply)(t) on thelow-voltage side of the LTC transformer at a predetermined voltage valueor within a predetermined range of voltage values.

The LTC transformer may include, for example, seventeen or more steps(thirty-five or more available positions), each of which may be selectedbased on the received load tap coefficients. Each change in step mayadjust the voltage component V_(Supply)(t) on the low voltage side ofthe LTC transformer by as little as, for example, about five-sixteenths(0.3%), or less.

Alternatively, the LTC transformer may include fewer than seventeensteps. Similarly, each change in step of the LTC transformer may adjustthe voltage component V_(Supply)(t) on the low voltage side of the LTCtransformer by more than, for example, about five-sixteenths (0.3%).

The voltage component V_(Supply)(t) may be measured and monitored on thelow voltage side of the LTC transformer by, for example, sampling orcontinuously measuring the voltage component V_(Supply)(t) of thestepped-down electrical power E_(Supply)(t) and storing the measuredvoltage component V_(Supply)(t) values as a function of time t in astorage (not shown), such as, for example, a computer readable medium.The voltage component V_(Supply)(t) may be monitored on, for example, asubstation distribution bus, or the like. Further, the voltage componentV_(Supply)(t) may be measured at any point where measurements could bemade for the transmission or distribution systems in the ER system 500.

Similarly, the voltage component V_(In)(t) of the electrical powerE_(In)(t) input to the high voltage side of the LTC transformer may bemeasured and monitored. Further, the current component I_(Supply)(t) ofthe stepped-down electrical power E_(Supply)(t) and the currentcomponent I_(In)(t) of the electrical power E_(In)(t) may also bemeasured and monitored. In this regard, a phase difference φ_(In)(t)between the voltage V_(In)(t) and current I_(In)(t) components of theelectrical power E_(In)(t) may be determined and monitored. Similarly, aphase difference φ_(Supply)(t) between the voltage V_(Supply)(t) andcurrent I_(Supply)(t) components of the electrical energy supplyE_(Supply)(t) may be determined and monitored.

The ER system 500 may provide electrical energy supply statusinformation to the EC system 400 on the communication links 430 or 510.The electrical energy supply information may include the monitoredvoltage component V_(Supply)(t). The electrical energy supplyinformation may further include the voltage component V_(In)(t), currentcomponents I_(In)(t), I_(Supply)(t), and/or phase difference valuesφ_(In)(t), φ_(Supply)(t), as a function of time t. The electrical energysupply status information may also include, for example, the load ratingof the LTC transformer.

The electrical energy supply status information may be provided to theEC system 400 at periodic intervals of time, such as, for example, everysecond, 5 sec., 10 sec., 30 sec., 60 sec., 120 sec., 600 sec., or anyother value within the scope and spirit of the disclosure, as determinedby one having ordinary skill in the art. The periodic intervals of timemay be set by the EC system 400 or the ER system 500. Alternatively, theelectrical energy supply status information may be provided to the ECsystem 400 or ER system 500 intermittently.

Further, the electrical energy supply status information may beforwarded to the EC system 400 in response to a request by the EC system400, or when a predetermined event is detected. The predetermined eventmay include, for example, when the voltage component V_(Supply)(t)changes by an amount greater (or less) than a defined threshold valueV_(SupplyThreshold) (for example, 130V) over a predetermined interval oftime, a temperature of one or more components in the ER system 500exceeds a defined temperature threshold, or the like.

ED System 300

The ED system 300 includes a plurality of smart meters 330. The EDsystem 300 may further include at least one collector 350, which isoptional. The ED system 300 may be coupled to the network 170 by meansof a communication link 310. The collector 350 may be coupled to theplurality of smart meters 330 by means of a communication link 320. Thesmart meters 330 may be coupled to the ER system 500 by means of one ormore power supply lines 340, which may also include communication links.Each smart meter 330 is configured to measure, store and report energyusage data by the associated users 150, 160 (shown in FIG. 1). Eachsmart meter 330 is further configured to measure and determine energyusage at the users 150, 160, including the voltage componentV_(Meter)(t) and current component I_(Meter)(t) of the electrical powerE_(Meter)(t) used by the users 150, 160, as a function of time. Thesmart meters 330 may measure the voltage component V_(Meter)(t) andcurrent component I_(Meter)(t) of the electrical power E_(Meter)(t) atdiscrete times t_(s), where s is a sampling period, such as, forexample, s=5 sec., 10 sec., 30 sec., 60 sec., 300 sec., 600 sec., ormore. For example, the smart meters 330 may measure energy usage every,for example, minute (t_(60 sec)), five minutes (t_(300 sec)), tenminutes (t_(600 sec)), or more, or at time intervals variably set by thesmart meter 330 (for example, using a random number generator).

The smart meters 330 may average the measured voltage V_(Meter)(t)and/or I_(Meter)(t) values over predetermined time intervals (forexample, 5 min., 10 min., 30 min., or more). The smart meters 330 maystore the measured electrical power usage E_(Meter)(t), including themeasured voltage component V_(Meter)(t) and/or current componentI_(Meter)(t) as smart meter data in a local (or remote) storage (notshown), such as, for example, a computer readable medium.

Each smart meter 330 is also capable of operating in a“report-by-exception” mode for any voltage V_(Meter)(t), currentI_(Meter)(t), or energy usage E_(Meter)(t) that falls outside of atarget component band. The target component band may include, a targetvoltage band, a target current band, or a target energy usage band. Inthe “report-by-exception” mode, the smart meter 330 may sua sponteinitiate communication and send smart meter data to the EC system 400.The “report-by-exception” mode may be used to reconfigure the smartmeters 330 used to represent, for example, the lowest voltages on thecircuit as required by changing system conditions.

The smart meter data may be periodically provided to the collector 350by means of the communication links 320. Additionally, the smart meters330 may provide the smart meter data in response to a smart meter datarequest signal received from the collector 350 on the communicationlinks 320.

Alternatively (or additionally), the smart meter data may beperiodically provided directly to the EC system 400 (for example, theMAS 460) from the plurality of smart meters, by means of, for example,communication links 320, 410 and network 170. In this regard, thecollector 350 may be bypassed, or eliminated from the ED system 300.Furthermore, the smart meters 330 may provide the smart meter datadirectly to the EC system 400 in response to a smart meter data requestsignal received from the EC system 400. In the absence of the collector350, the EC system (for example, the MAS 460) may carry out thefunctionality of the collector 350 described herein.

The request signal may include, for example, a query (or read) signaland a smart meter identification signal that identifies the particularsmart meter 330 from which smart meter data is sought. The smart meterdata may include the following information for each smart meter 130,including, for example, kilo-Watt-hours (kWh) delivered data, kWhreceived data, kWh delivered plus kWh received data, kWh delivered minuskWh received data, voltage level data, current level data, phase anglebetween voltage and current, kVar data, time interval data, demand data,and the like.

Additionally, the smart meters 330 may send the smart meter data to themeter automation system server MAS 460. The smart meter data may be sentto the MAS 460 periodically according to a predetermined schedule orupon request from the MAS 460.

The collector 350 is configured to receive the smart meter data fromeach of the plurality of smart meters 330 via the communication links320. The collector 350 stores the received smart meter data in a localstorage (not shown), such as, for example, a computer readable medium.The collector 350 compiles the received smart meter data into acollector data. In this regard, the received smart meter data may beaggregated into the collector data based on, for example, a geographiczone in which the smart meters 330 are located, a particular time band(or range) during which the smart meter data was collected, a subset ofsmart meters 330 identified in a collector control signal, and the like.In compiling the received smart meter data, the collector 350 mayaverage the voltage component V_(Meter)(t) values received in the smartmeter data from all (or a subset of all) of the smart meters 330.

The EC system 400 is able to select or alter a subset of all of thesmart meters 330 to be monitored for predetermined time intervals, whichmay include for example 15 minute intervals. It is noted that thepredetermined time intervals may be shorter or longer than 15 minutes.The subset of all of the smart meters 330 is selectable and can bealtered by the EC system 400 as needed to maintain minimum level controlof the voltage V_(Supply)(t) supplied to the smart meters 330.

The collector 350 may also average the electrical power E_(Meter)(t)values received in the smart meter data from all (or a subset of all) ofthe smart meters 330. The compiled collector data may be provided by thecollector 350 to the EC system 400 by means of the communication link310 and network 170. For example, the collector 350 may send thecompiled collector data to the MAS 460 (or ROC 490) in the EC system400.

The collector 350 is configured to receive collector control signalsover the network 170 and communication link 310 from the EC system 400.Based on the received collector control signals, the collector 350 isfurther configured to select particular ones of the plurality of smartmeters 330 and query the meters for smart meter data by sending a smartmeter data request signal to the selected smart meters 330. Thecollector 350 may then collect the smart meter data that it receivesfrom the selected smart meters 330 in response to the queries. Theselectable smart meters 330 may include any one or more of the pluralityof smart meters 330. The collector control signals may include, forexample, an identification of the smart meters 330 to be queried (orread), time(s) at which the identified smart meters 330 are to measurethe V_(Meter)(t), I_(Meter)(t), E_(Meter)(t) and/or φ_(Meter)(t)(φ_(Meter)(t) is the phase difference between the voltage V_(Meter)(t)and current I_(Meter)(t) components of the electrical power E_(Meter)(t)measured at the identified smart meter 330), energy usage informationsince the last reading from the identified smart meter 330, and thelike. The collector 350 may then compile and send the compiled collectordata to the MAS 460 (and/or ROC 490) in the EC system 400.

EC System 400

The EC system 400 may communicate with the ED system 300 and/or ERsystem 500 by means of the network 170. The EC system 400 is coupled tothe network 170 by means of one or more communication links 410. The ECsystem 400 may also communicate directly with the ER system 500 by meansof a communication link 430.

The EC system 400 includes the MAS 460, a database (DB) 470, adistribution management system (DMS) 480, and a regional operationcenter (ROC) 490. The ROC 490 may include a computer (ROC computer) 495,a server (not shown) and a database (not shown). The MAS 460 may becoupled to the DB 470 and DMS 480 by means of communication links 420and 440, respectively. The DMS 480 may be coupled to the ROC 490 and ERSYSTEM 500 by means of the communication link 430. The database 470 maybe located at the same location as (for example, proximate to, orwithin) the MAS 460, or at a remote location that may be accessible via,for example, the network 170.

The EC system 400 is configured to de-select, from the subset ofmonitored smart meters 330, a smart meter 330 that the EC system 400previously selected to monitor, and select the smart meter 330 that isoutside of the subset of monitored smart meters 330, but which isoperating in the report-by-exception mode. The EC system 400 may carryout this change after receiving the sua sponte smart meter data from thenon-selected smart meter 330. In this regard, the EC system 400 mayremove or terminate a connection to the de-selected smart meter 330 andcreate a new connection to the newly selected smart meter 330 operatingin the report-by-exception mode. The EC system 400 is further configuredto select any one or more of the plurality of smart meters 330 fromwhich it receives smart meter data comprising, for example, the lowestmeasured voltage component V_(Meter)(t), and generate an energy deliveryparameter C_(ED) based on the smart meter data received from the smartmeter(s) 330 that provide the lowest measured voltage componentV_(Meter)(t).

The MAS 460 may include a computer (not shown) that is configured toreceive the collector data from the collector 350, which includes smartmeter data collected from a selected subset (or all) of the smart meters330. The MAS 460 is further configured to retrieve and forward smartmeter data to the ROC 490 in response to queries received from the ROC490. The MAS 460 may store the collector data, including smart meterdata in a local storage and/or in the DB 470.

The DMS 480 may include a computer that is configured to receive theelectrical energy supply status information from the substation 530. TheDMS 480 is further configured to retrieve and forward measured voltagecomponent V_(Meter)(t) values and electrical power E_(Meter)(t) valuesin response to queries received from the ROC 490. The DMS 480 may befurther configured to retrieve and forward measured current componentI_(Meter)(t) values in response to queries received from the ROC 490.The DMS 480 also may be further configured to retrieve all“report-by-exception” voltages V_(Meter)(t) from the smart meters 330operating in the “report-by-exception” mode and designate the voltagesV_(Meter)(t) as one of the control points to be continuously read atpredetermined times (for example, every 15 minutes, or less (or more),or at varying times). The “report-by-exception voltages V_(Meter)(t) maybe used to control the EC 500 set points.

The DB 470 may include a plurality of relational databases (not shown).The DB 470 includes a large number of records that include historicaldata for each smart meter 330, each collector 350, each substation 530,and the geographic area(s) (including latitude, longitude, and altitude)where the smart meters 330, collectors 350, and substations 530 arelocated.

For instance, the DB 470 may include any one or more of the followinginformation for each smart meter 330, including: a geographic location(including latitude, longitude, and altitude); a smart meteridentification number; an account number; an account name; a billingaddress; a telephone number; a smart meter type, including model andserial number; a date when the smart meter was first placed into use; atime stamp of when the smart meter was last read (or queried); the smartmeter data received at the time of the last reading; a schedule of whenthe smart meter is to be read (or queried), including the types ofinformation that are to be read; and the like.

The historical smart meter data may include, for example, the electricalpower E_(Meter)(t) used by the particular smart meter 330, as a functionof time. Time t may be measured in, for example, discrete intervals atwhich the electrical power E_(Meter) magnitude (kWh) of the receivedelectrical power E_(Meter)(t) is measured or determined at the smartmeter 330. The historical smart meter data includes a measured voltagecomponent V_(Meter)(t) of the electrical energy E_(Meter)(t) received atthe smart meter 330. The historical smart meter data may further includea measured current component I_(Meter)(t) and/or phase differenceφ_(Meter)(t) of the electrical power E_(Meter)(t) received at the smartmeter 330.

As noted earlier, the voltage component V_(Meter)(t) may be measured ata sampling period of, for example, every five seconds, ten seconds,thirty seconds, one minute, five minutes, ten minutes, fifteen minutes,or the like. The current component I_(Meter)(t) and/or the receivedelectrical power E_(Meter)(t) values may also be measured atsubstantially the same times as the voltage component V_(Meter)(t).

Given the low cost of memory, the DB 470 may include historical datafrom the very beginning of when the smart meter data was first collectedfrom the smart meters 330 through to the most recent smart meter datareceived from the smart meter 330 s.

The DB 470 may include a time value associated with each measuredvoltage component V_(Meter)(t), current component I_(Meter)(t), phasecomponent φ_(Meter)(t) and/or electrical power E_(Meter)(t), which mayinclude a timestamp value generated at the smart meter 330. Thetimestamp value may include, for example, a year, a month, a day, anhour, a minute, a second, and a fraction of a second. Alternatively, thetimestamp may be a coded value which may be decoded to determine a year,a month, a day, an hour, a minute, a second, and a fraction of a second,using, for example, a look up table. The ROC 490 and/or smart meters 330may be configured to receive, for example, a WWVB atomic clock signaltransmitted by the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology(NIST), or the like and synchronize its internal clock (not shown) tothe WWVB atomic clock signal.

The historical data in the DB 470 may further include historicalcollector data associated with each collector 350. The historicalcollector data may include any one or more of the following information,including, for example: the particular smart meters 330 associated witheach collector 350; the geographic location (including latitude,longitude, and altitude) of each collector 350; a collector type,including model and serial number; a date when the collector 350 wasfirst placed into use; a time stamp of when collector data was lastreceived from the collector 350; the collector data that was received; aschedule of when the collector 350 is expected to send collector data,including the types of information that are to be sent; and the like.

The historical collector data may further include, for example, anexternal temperature value T_(Collector)(t) measured outside of eachcollector 350 at time t. The historical collector data may furtherinclude, for example, any one or more of the following for eachcollector 350: an atmospheric pressure value P_(Collector)(t) measuredproximate the collector 350 at time t; a humidity value H_(Collector)(t)measured proximate the collector 350 at time t; a wind vector valueW_(Collector)(t) measured proximate the collector 350 at time t,including direction and magnitude of the measured wind; a solarirradiant value L_(Collector)(t) (kW/m²) measured proximate thecollector 350 at time t; and the like.

The historical data in the DB 470 may further include historicalsubstation data associated with each substation 530. The historicalsubstation data may include any one or more of the followinginformation, including, for example: the identifications of theparticular smart meters 330 supplied with electrical energyE_(Supply)(t) by the substation 530; the geographic location (includinglatitude, longitude, and altitude) of the substation 530; the number ofdistribution circuits; the number of transformers; a transformer type ofeach transformer, including model, serial number and maximum MegavoltAmpere (MVA) rating; the number of voltage regulators; a voltageregulator type of each voltage regulator, including model and serialnumber; a time stamp of when substation data was last received from thesubstation 530; the substation data that was received; a schedule ofwhen the substation 530 is expected to provide electrical energy supplystatus information, including the types of information that are to beprovided; and the like.

The historical substation data may include, for example, the electricalpower E_(Supply)(t) supplied to each particular smart meter 330, whereE_(Supply)(t) is measured or determined at the output of the substation530. The historical substation data includes a measured voltagecomponent V_(Supply)(t) of the supplied electrical power E_(Supply)(t),which may be measured, for example, on the distribution bus (not shown)from the transformer. The historical substation data may further includea measured current component I_(Supply)(t) of the supplied electricalpower E_(Supply)(t). As noted earlier, the voltage componentV_(Supply)(t), the current component I_(Supply)(t), and/or theelectrical power E_(Supply)(t) may be measured at a sampling period of,for example, every five seconds, ten seconds, thirty seconds, a minute,five minutes, ten minutes, or the like. The historical substation datamay further include a phase difference value φ_(Supply)(t) between thevoltage V_(Supply)(t) and current I_(Supply)(t) signals of theelectrical power E_(Supply)(t), which may be used to determine the powerfactor of the electrical power E_(Supply)(t) supplied to the smartmeters 330.

The historical substation data may further include, for example, theelectrical power E_(In)(t) received on the line 520 at the input of thesubstation 530, where the electrical power E_(In)(t) is measured ordetermined at the input of the substation 530. The historical substationdata may include a measured voltage component V_(In)(t) of the receivedelectrical power E_(In)(t), which may be measured, for example, at theinput of the transformer. The historical substation data may furtherinclude a measured current component I_(In)(t) of the receivedelectrical power E_(In)(t). As noted earlier, the voltage componentV_(In)(t), the current component I_(In)(t), and/or the electrical powerE_(In)(t) may be measured at a sampling period of, for example, everyfive seconds, ten seconds, thirty seconds, a minute, five minutes, tenminutes, or the like. The historical substation data may further includea phase difference φ_(In)(t) between the voltage component V_(In)(t) andcurrent component I_(In)(t) of the electrical power E_(In)(t). The powerfactor of the electrical power E_(In)(t) may be determined based on thephase difference φ_(In)(t).

According to an aspect of the disclosure, the EC system 400 may saveaggregated kW data at the substation level, voltage data at thesubstation level, and weather data to compare to energy usage per smartmeter 330 to determine the energy savings from the VCC system 200, andusing linear regression to remove the effects of weather, load growth,economic effects, and the like, from the calculation.

In the VCC system 200, control may be initiated from, for example, theROC computer 495. In this regard, a control screen 305 may be displayedon the ROC computer 495, as shown, for example, in FIG. 3 of U.S.publication 2013/0030591. The control screen 305 may correspond to datafor a particular substation 530 (for example, the TRABUE SUBSTATION) inthe ER system 500. The ROC computer 495 can control and override (ifnecessary), for example, the substation 530 load tap changingtransformer based on, for example, the smart meter data received fromthe ED system 300 for the users 150, 160. The ED system 300 maydetermine the voltages of the electrical power supplied to the userlocations 150, 160, at predetermined (or variable) intervals, such as,e.g., on average each 15 minutes, while maintaining the voltages withinrequired voltage limits.

For system security, the substation 530 may be controlled through thedirect communication link 430 from the ROC 490 and/or DMS 480, includingtransmission of data through communication link 430 to and from the ER500, EUS 300 and EVP 600.

Furthermore, an operator can initiate a voltage control program on theROC computer 490, overriding the controls, if necessary, and monitoringa time it takes to read the user voltages V_(Meter)(t) being used forcontrol of, for example, the substation LTC transformer (not shown) inthe ER system 500.

FIG. 3 shows the energy validation process 600 for determining theamount of conservation in energy per customer realized by operating theVCC system in FIGS. 1-2. The process is started 601 and the data the ONand OFF periods is loaded 602 by the process manager. The next step isto collect 603 the hourly voltage and power (MW) data from the meteringdata points on the VCC system from the DMS 480 which may be part of asupervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) type of industrialcontrol system. Next the corresponding weather data is collected 604 forthe same hourly conditions. The data is processed 605, 606, 607, 608 toimprove its quality using filters and analysis techniques to eliminateoutliers that could incorrectly affect the results, as describe furtherbelow. If hourly pairing is to be done the hourly groups are determined609 using the linear regression techniques. The next major step is todetermine 611, 612, 613, 614, 615, 616, 617 the optimal pairing of thesamples, as described further below.

FIG. 4 shows an example of the database structure where the initial datafor analysis is kept. This relational data base allows for fastprocessing of the data and marking of data that is not to be usedbecause of the anomalies. The efficient storage of the data forcontinued analysis is useful to provide the evaluation performance forthe EVP.

FIG. 5 shows an example of an application of the data quality reviews ofthe data before processing. Using the database the values are scannedfor out of range levels in all categories, such as the zero MW readings622 and the very low voltage readings 623. These are identified andremoved before processing. Second, it shows repeated values, such as therepeated voltage reading of 122.331 volts in the data box 621, that areindicative of bad measurements and would severely degrade thecalculation of the energy change. These are also removed from the futurecalculations. Known anomalies, including missing records due to daylightsavings time changes 624, are removed as well.

FIG. 6 shows an example of a frequency plot of voltage at hourlyintervals. It is expected that most of the data will follow a normalizedform when analyzed. This makes it easier to spot poor quality data inthe outlier data as shown here. Data are reviewed using the frequencyplots and the outliers are reviewed for consistency with normaloperating conditions on the system. The outliers, such as voltages 623,can be eliminated if they fall outside of predetermined bands. This isan example of analysis applied to all of the variables.

FIG. 7 shows an example of histogram plots of the “OFF” to “ON” datacomparisons for both voltage and MW. As is seen on the top two diagramsthe voltage for the “ON” state has a significantly wider deviation thatthe “OFF” data. This is also a concern when the standard deviation ofthe comparison data does not match. Data sets having out of range ornon-matching standard deviations may be filtered out. In contrast the MWdata had very consistent standard deviations and very little differencesin the “ON” to “OFF” state population characteristics.

FIG. 8 shows an example of the comparison of scatterplots of the “OFF”(black points on the scatterplots) to “ON” (red points on thescatterplots) populations by season and by group. These plots are usefulfor reviews of the level of the sampling across the entire performancelevels. As can be seen from these examples there are a number of areas624, 625 where there are no “ON” samples for large areas of the “OFF”performance levels. This means that more sampling will be needed toaccurately represent these conservation performance zones. The quickreview of the scatterplots can give a significant knowledge of thesample size and adequacy for this type of measurement.

FIG. 9 shows an example of the high level pairing process which is basedon a well-established statistical comparison technique called paired t.The purpose of this calculation is to compare two samples of data todetermine the average shift in a variable mean from one sample set tothe other. Documentation of the details of paired t analysis can befound in a number of standard statistic publications and is readilyavailable in standard software packages. FIG. 9 is a high leveldescription of the process being applied to the Substation 530Transformer and ED 300 circuit MW and Voltage data. The value beingcalculated is the CVR factor which establishes the ratio of (a) thepercent power (watts) change from sample 1 (P1) to sample 2 (P2) to (b)the percent voltage (volts) change from sample 1 (V1) to sample 2 (V2).The CVR factor=((P1−P2)P1)/((V1−V2)/V1). Sample 1 is take from the MWand Voltage data at the meter when the CVR control system is “OFF” andSample 2 is taken from the data when CVR is “ON”. A larger CVR factorindicates more power savings from reduction in voltage, with commonobserved CVR factors for some CVR systems being observed in the range ofabout 0.2 to 1.2.

Sets of samples are paired using the rules of FIG. 9. Records 1 and 2 inFIG. 9 are for Samples 1 and 2 respectively. For Samples 1 and 2: theimmediately upstream transformer (TX #1) must be the same (=); theStatus (e.g., whether CVR is OFF or ON) must be different (<>), the DayType (e.g., workday, weekend or holiday) must be equal (=); Coolingdegree days and heating degree days (CDD/HDD) should each be matchedwithin plus or minus one degree day (±1 DD), and relative humidityshould be matched within plus or minus five percent (±5% RH). Thismatching of two samples from the “OFF” and “ON” states creates one pairof samples. Once paired, the volts and power from the Samples 1 and 2may be used for the CVR factor calculation. At least 30 of these pairsare required for the calculation of the average difference between thetwo sample sets to have statistical significance (about a 95% confidencelevel).

There are three features of the paired t analysis for the illustratedembodiment. First the paired samples are independent. This requires thatfor each sample taken from a data set, whether for sample 1 (OFF state)or sample 2 (ON state), the values from the sample can only be used andpaired one time in the analysis. Once they are used, the samples areremoved from the data sets to choose the next pair. The second featureis that the data sets are normal data sets. This is checkedstatistically for each analysis. Normality is checked using theAnderson-Darling normality test. Third, the number of paired t samplesare greater than about 30 to be statistically significant. Thiscalculation will be shown for each set of analysis. Once these threefeatures are present, the paired t analysis is implemented and theaverage difference is determined within a confidence interval determinedby the variation of the paired samples. The illustrated embodiment uses95% confidence level for the CVR analysis.

FIG. 10 shows an example of a method used for decreasing the variationin the calculation by separating the samples into consistent groups. Forthe MW and Voltage data this is done by grouping the sample data intolike hours that are consistent with each other. This may be done with alinear regression technique. Using linear regression, the consistency ofthe variables is checked. Samples taken in the same hour of the day(hours 0 through 23 in the heading of the table of FIG. 10) are groupedand are noted in the same column in FIG. 10. Sample hours that representlike data are determined by using the linear regression constants tocheck consistency between hours that are grouped together. In additioneach data set is grouped into a seasonal grouping as well. The result ofthis grouping process is to first break the sample data up into theseasonal groups of winter, spring, summer and fall. Then using thelinear regression break the hours for each seasonal day (0 to 23) intolike groups for paired t testing. This technique will lessen thevariation in the paired t calculation for average difference from onesample group to another. The table in FIG. 10 is an example of this typeof process.

FIG. 11 shows the detailed pairing process for a multiple variableexample of the VCC pairing both HDD/CDD along with humidity. The processcreates a total list of possible matched pairs in all combinations. Eachpair is scored based on a linear optimization method to weigh theindependent variable appropriately based on its energy effect and usethe linearization to form the optimal scoring for the pair includingboth independent variables of HDD/CDD and humidity using linearregression constants. For example, if the energy effect (e.g., change inCVR factor) for HDD/CDD is five times the energy effect for humidity, adifference in HDD/CDD between samples is weighted five times as much asthe difference in humidity between samples.

Once this process is complete the list is reviewed for the best score.These are paired and removed from the pairing list. The process isrepeated for each of the remaining pairs until all pairs have beenoptimally matched for variables within the tolerance levels as shown inthe process diagram of FIG. 11. In this way the pairing is optimized tothe population giving the best accuracy for the data available,according to the illustrated embodiment with the given criteria.

FIG. 12 shows an example of the histogram of the data from the CVRfactor pairing calculation. It is noted that the pairing is normalizedand fits the characteristics of the t-distribution. With thisinformation the data can be used to evaluate the range of average valuesof the CVR factor for the circuit during the time period the data wastaken. This data can be calculated for a data set of 30 or more and willproduce an accurate representation of the range of the CVR factor. Eachdata set requires a one-day time period. Normally the 95% confidenceinterval is used to determine a usable range for the CVR factor. Thisstatistical factor is specifically for the circuit under evaluation andprovides ongoing evaluation of the performance of the circuit down to aminimum of 30 data sets and thus a 30-day interval.

FIG. 13 shows an example of the histogram and the scatterplot of theenergy saving per customer over the interval from the same paired tanalysis. The top graph is a measure of the kW/customer change and hasthe same type of normalized characteristic that is compatible with thet-distribution confidence interval analysis. The scatterplot of thepaired population plotted in an “OFF” to “ON” state give a quickintuitive evaluation of the paired data. In general if the majority ofthe pairs are below the red line the VCC system is improving theconservation, if they are equally spaced on either side of the line itis not having any effect and if they are on average above the line it ishaving the reverse effect. In this case it is easy to see that thesamples are clearly showing improvement in conservation of energy.

FIG. 14 shows an alternative example of the CVR factor analysis foranother circuit. The graph on the right of FIG. 14. demonstrates thecharacteristics for a measurement done without the control circuit beingused to compensate for the other independent variables. The results showa non-normal population with a much higher CVR savings. In this casethere was a substantial decrease in load because of lower electricitydemand due to the downturn in the economy, thus making the CVR factorlook abnormally high. The graph on the left of FIG. 14 is with thecontrol circuit and uses the circuit to remove the non-normal effects ofthe negative economic growth. The CVR factor using this control circuitdoes decrease but the normality becomes very strong and the data is backin a normal range for the VCC control system to be the only independentvariable controlling the effects.

FIG. 15 shows an example of the final calculations on both the CVRfactor and the savings in energy derive from the optimal pairing of theVCC system energy. This results in a direct calculation of the capacityof the circuit to reduce energy as stated in the CVR factor. Thiscapacity is its ability to conserve energy by reducing voltage in thelower operating band. The VCC system executes this type of control andthe EVP independently calculates the capacity of the circuit to continueto conserve as other modifications to the voltage performance areimplemented.

FIG. 15 also shows an example of the final calculations for energysavings during the measurement time under study. This energy savings isa continuous reporting of the circuit's ability to continue to sustainthe conservation savings that were calculated for the VCC system. Thisability to continuously track the performance instead of having to dorepeated one time testing of the circuit to estimate the performancerepresents a major step forward in the technology. Existing systems arebased on one time tests that greatly reduce the efficiency performancejust to estimate the CVR factor and the energy saving performance. Inaddition they must be repeated on regular intervals to determine if thesaving is being sustained. This EVP system provides a major step forwardin being able to generate near metered savings without reducing theefficiency of the VCC system.

While the disclosure has been described in terms of exemplaryembodiments, those skilled in the art will recognize that the disclosurecan be practiced with modifications in the spirit and scope of theappended claims. These examples are merely illustrative and are notmeant to be an exhaustive list of all possible designs, embodiments,applications or modifications of the disclosure.

What is claimed as new and desired to be protected by Letters Patent ofthe United States is:
 1. A control system for an electric power gridconfigured to supply electric power from a supply point to a pluralityof consumption locations, the system comprising: a plurality of sensors,wherein each sensor is located at a respective one of a plurality ofdistribution locations on the electric power grid at or between thesupply point and at least one of the plurality of consumption locations,and wherein each sensor is configured to sense at least one component ofa supplied electric power received at the respective consumptionlocation and at least one of the plurality of sensors is configured togenerate measurement data based on the sensed component of the power; acontroller configured to receive the measurement data from the sensorsand to communicate with at least one component adjusting device toadjust a component of the electric power grid, wherein the controller isconfigured to operate the electric power grid in a modification-on stateor in a modification-off state and to determine a change in energycharacteristics between the modification-on state and themodification-off state, using a paired t measurement, and wherein thepaired t measurement determines an average shift in a mean energy usage.wherein the at least one component adjusting device is configured toadjust a component of the electric power grid based on the measurementdata.
 2. The control system of claim 1, wherein the modification-onstate is a conservation voltage reduction (CVR) “ON” state and themodification-off state is a CVR “OFF” state.
 3. The control system ofclaim 1, wherein the sensed component of the power is at least one ofvoltage and energy, and the sensed component of the power is measured onan interval basis.
 4. The control system of claim 1, wherein themodification-on state is a conservation voltage reduction (CVR) “ON”state and the modification-off state is a CVR “OFF” state and whereinthe paired t measurement includes a pairing process to determine a CVRfactor for the electric power grid.
 5. The control system of claim 4,wherein the pairing process includes measurements of CVR factor and/orconservation energy savings by season and uses at least one linearregression constant to determine the blocks of hours where consistentloads exist.
 6. The control system of claim 4, wherein the pairingprocess comprises pairing a CVR “ON” record to a CVR “OFF” record andthe CVR “OFF” record has a predetermined first independent variableassociated with the CVR “OFF” record within a first independent variabletolerance of the first independent variable associated with the pairedCVR “ON” record.
 7. The control system of claim 6, wherein the CVR “OFF”record has a second independent variable associated with the CVR “OFF”record within a predetermined second independent variable tolerance ofthe second independent variable associated with the paired CVR “ON”record.
 8. The control system of claim 2, wherein the controller isconfigured to apply CVR to generate a CVR energy delivery parameterbased on the measurement data when the controller is in the CVR “ON”state, but not when the controller is in the CVR “OFF” state.
 9. Thecontrol system of claim 1, wherein the at least one component adjustingdevice is configured to adjust a voltage set point value of theelectrical power supplied at the supply point to the plurality ofconsumption locations based on the change in energy characteristics. 10.The control system of claim 1, wherein the controller is furtherconfigured to adjust the at least one component adjusting device basedon the change in energy characteristics.
 11. The control system of claim1, wherein the energy characteristic is a CVR factor.
 12. The controlsystem of claim 1, wherein the energy characteristic is the energysavings.
 13. The control system of claim 3, wherein each meter'smeasurement data is averaged over the interval.
 14. The system of claim3, wherein the interval is a period of at least one of twenty-fourhours, four hours, and one hour.
 15. The control system of claim 1,wherein the at least one component adjusting device includes a load tapchange transformer configured to adjust a voltage of the electric powersupplied at the supply point based on a load tap change coefficientand/or a voltage regulator that adjusts a voltage of the electric powersupplied at the supply point.
 16. The control system of claim 1, whereinthe controller is configured to use a paired t p-factor to eliminatedata having values outside of corresponding predetermined normalizedranges of values to determine measurement accuracy.
 17. The controlsystem of claim 1, wherein the controller is configured to determine thechange in energy characteristic based on a first pairing variable. 18.The control system of claim 17, wherein the first variable is season,grouped hour, or customer type.
 19. The control system of claim 17,wherein the controller is configured to provide a second pairingvariable that is secondary to the first pairing variable, to pair thefirst variable values to the closest modification-off to modification-onvalues, and to determine a weighed scoring of the pairs based on therelative slopes of the linear relationship between the first and secondrespective variables.
 20. The control system of claim 1, wherein thecontroller is configured to exclude data that is affected bynon-efficiency variables.
 21. The control system of claim 1, wherein thecontroller is further configured to receive measurement data from eachsensor of a subset of the plurality of sensors, and the subset is fewerthen all of the plurality of sensors receiving supplied electric power.22. The control system of claim 21, wherein the controller is furtherconfigured to receive a signal indicating that the measured component ofelectric power sensed by at least one other sensor of the plurality ofsensors is outside of a sensor target component band, and wherein thecontroller is further configured to add to the subset the at least oneother sensor in response to receiving the signal indicating that themeasured component of electric power sensed by the at least one othersensor is outside of the sensor target component band.
 23. A computerreadable media having instructions for a control system for an electricpower grid configured to supply electric power from a supply point to aplurality of consumption locations, the instructions comprising: asensor receiving instruction configured to receive measurement data fromat least one of a plurality of sensors, wherein each sensor is locatedat a respective one of a plurality of distribution locations on theelectric power grid at or between the supply point and at least one ofthe plurality of consumption locations, and wherein each sensor isconfigured to sense at least one component of a supplied electric powerreceived at the respective distribution location, a plurality ofsensors, wherein each sensor is located at a respective one of aplurality of distribution locations on the electric power grid at orbetween the supply point and at least one of the plurality ofconsumption locations, and wherein each sensor is configured to sense atleast one component of a supplied electric power received at therespective consumption location and at least one of the plurality ofsensors is configured to generate measurement data based on the sensedcomponent of the power; a controller configured to receive themeasurement data from the sensors and to communicate with at least onecomponent adjusting device to adjust a component of the electric powergrid, wherein the controller is configured to operate the electric powergrid in a modification-on state or in a modification-off state and todetermine a change in energy characteristics between the modification-onstate and the modification-off state, using a paired t measurement, andwherein the paired t measurement determines an average shift in a meanenergy usage. wherein the at least one component adjusting device isconfigured to adjust a component of the electric power grid based on themeasurement data.
 24. The computer readable media of claim 23, whereinthe modification-on state is a conservation voltage reduction (CVR) “ON”state and the modification-off state is a CVR “OFF” state.
 25. Thecomputer readable media of claim 23, wherein the sensed component of thepower is at least one of voltage and energy, and the sensed component ofthe power is measured on an interval basis.
 26. The computer readablemedia of claim 23, wherein the modification-on state is a conservationvoltage reduction (CVR) “ON” state and the modification-off state is aCVR “OFF” state and wherein the paired t measurement includes a pairingprocess to determine a CVR factor for the electric power grid.
 27. Thecomputer readable media of claim 26, wherein the pairing processincludes measurements of CVR factor and/or conservation energy savingsby season and uses at least one linear regression constant to determinethe blocks of hours where consistent loads exist.
 28. The computerreadable media of claim 26, wherein the pairing process comprisespairing a CVR “ON” record to a CVR “OFF” record and the CVR “OFF” recordhas a predetermined first independent variable associated with the CVR“OFF” record within a first independent variable tolerance of the firstindependent variable associated with the paired CVR “ON” record.
 29. Thecomputer readable media of claim 28, wherein the CVR “OFF” record has asecond independent variable associated with the CVR “OFF” record withina predetermined second independent variable tolerance of the secondindependent variable associated with the paired CVR “ON” record.
 30. Thecomputer readable media of claim 24, wherein the controller instructionis configured to apply CVR to generate a CVR energy delivery parameterbased on the measurement data when the controller is in the CVR “ON”state, but not when the controller is in the CVR “OFF” state.
 31. Thecomputer readable media of claim 23, wherein the at least one componentadjusting device is configured to adjust a voltage set point value ofthe electrical power supplied at the supply point to the plurality ofconsumption locations based on the change in energy characteristics. 32.The computer readable media of claim 23, wherein the controllerinstruction is further configured to adjust the at least one componentadjusting device based on the change in energy characteristics.
 33. Thecomputer readable media of claim 23, wherein the energy characteristicis a CVR factor.
 34. The computer readable media of claim 23, whereinthe energy characteristic is the energy savings.
 35. The computerreadable media of claim 25, wherein each meter's measurement data isaveraged over the interval.
 36. The system of claim 25, wherein theinterval is a period of at least one of twenty-four hours, four hours,and one hour.
 37. The computer readable media of claim 23, wherein theat least one component adjusting device includes a load tap changetransformer configured to adjust a voltage of the electric powersupplied at the supply point based on a load tap change coefficientand/or a voltage regulator that adjusts a voltage of the electric powersupplied at the supply point.
 38. The computer readable media of claim23, wherein the controller instruction is configured to use a paired tp-factor to eliminate data having values outside of correspondingpredetermined normalized ranges of values to determine measurementaccuracy.
 39. The computer readable media of claim 23, wherein thecontroller instruction is configured to determine the change in energycharacteristic based on a first pairing variable.
 40. The computerreadable media of claim 39, wherein the first variable is season,grouped hour, or customer type.
 41. The computer readable media of claim39, wherein the controller instruction is configured to provide a secondpairing variable that is secondary to the first pairing variable, topair the first variable values to the closest modification-off tomodification-on values, and to determine a weighed scoring of the pairsbased on the relative slopes of the linear relationship between thefirst and second respective variables.
 42. The computer readable mediaof claim 23, wherein the controller instruction is configured to excludedata that is affected by non-efficiency variables.
 43. The computerreadable media of claim 23, wherein the controller instruction isfurther configured to receive measurement data from each sensor of asubset of the plurality of sensors, and the subset is fewer then all ofthe plurality of sensors receiving supplied electric power.
 44. Thecomputer readable media of claim 43, wherein the controller instructionis further configured to receive a signal indicating that the measuredcomponent of electric power sensed by at least one other sensor of theplurality of sensors is outside of a sensor target component band, andwherein the controller instruction is further configured to add to thesubset the at least one other sensor in response to receiving the signalindicating that the measured component of electric power sensed by theat least one other sensor is outside of the sensor target componentband.